State & Institutional Discrimination

Education Minister Says ‘Sharifa’s Story’ Will Be Changed If It Causes Confusion






Education Minister Says ‘Sharifa’s Story’ Will Be Changed If It Causes Confusion


23 January 2024 | Dhaka, Bangladesh

Bangladesh’s Education Minister Mohibul Hasan Chowdhury Nowfel said on 23 January 2024 that the government would consider changing “Sharifa’s Story” in the seventh-grade History and Social Science textbook if any confusion or misrepresentation was found in its presentation. His remarks came amid growing controversy over the story, which presents the experiences of a Hijra person as part of the national curriculum. The controversy had intensified after Asif Mahtab Utsha, a part-time lecturer at BRAC University, publicly tore pages containing the story during a seminar organised by Jatiya Shikkhok Forum on 19 January, with video of the incident subsequently circulating on social media.

Speaking to journalists at the Secretariat in Dhaka, the education minister said the content would be examined in consultation with experts and the National Curriculum and Textbook Board (NCTB). Responding to objections raised over the terminology and content of the story, he said Hijra people were legally recognised citizens of Bangladesh and had rights under the law. He also stated that some groups were using religious sentiments around the issue to create instability, while saying that any genuine confusion in the textbook should be addressed through expert review.

Nowfel said that if experts identified confusion or problems in the way the story had been presented, the government would make the necessary changes. At the same time, he said any review should ensure that Hijra people were not disrespected. His statement marked the government’s first public indication during the controversy that the textbook content could be revised following the objections and debate surrounding “Sharifa’s Story.”

References

Bangla Tribune — ‘শরীফা’ গল্পে বিভ্রান্তি থাকলে পরিবর্তন আনা হবে: শিক্ষামন্ত্রী — 23 January 2024
United News of Bangladesh (UNB) — Education Minister Addresses Controversy over ‘Sharifa’s Story’ in Textbook — 23 January 2024
The Financial Express — Education Minister Addresses Controversy over ‘Sharifa’s Story’ — 23 January 2024
Dhaka Tribune — Education Minister Addresses Controversy over ‘Sharifa’s Story’ — 23 January 2024

Updates on this case

Sharifa’s Story · 19 reports

  1. January 2023 Bangladesh Introduces Hijra Representation in School Textbook
  2. 19 January 2024 Asif Mahtab ripped a Grade 7 textbook page on a transgender story and urged others to do the same
  3. 20 January 2024 Education Minister Takes Anti-Transgender Stance in Meeting with Hefazat-e-Islam
  4. 21 January 2024 BRAC University will not renew Asif Mahtab’s contract over textbook-tearing protest
  5. 22 January 2024 Teachers’ Forum Demands Reinstatement of Controversial Lecturer Asif Mahtab
  6. 23 January 2024 Jamaat-e-Islami statement praises Asif Mahtab & criticizes government
  7. 23 January 2024 Extremist Islamist student group at BRAC University rallies for Asif Mahtab
  8. 23 January 2024 Education Minister Says ‘Sharifa’s Story’ Will Be Changed If It Causes Confusion
  9. 24 January 2024 JaSaD demands immediate arrest of ‘extremist’ Asif Mahtab
  10. 24 January 2024 Mahila Parishad has questioned Asif Mahtab’s qualifications as a teacher
  11. 24 January 2024 Education Ministry Forms Committee with Religious Scholars to Review ‘Sharifa’s Story’
  12. 25 January 2024 Statement of Hefazat-e-Islam in favor of Asif Mahatab
  13. 25 January 2024 Legal Notice Seeks Removal of ‘Sharifa’s Story’ from School Textbook
  14. 26 January 2024 Islami Andolan Bangladesh Protests Against ‘Sharifa’s Story’ and Transgender Content
  15. 29 January 2024 BRAC University explains non-renewal of Asif Mahtab’s contract
  16. 16 May 2024 Review Committee Recommends Removal of ‘Sharifa’s Story’ from Textbook
  17. 17 May 2024 Udichi Protests Recommendation to Remove ‘Sharifa’s Story’ from Textbook
  18. 25 June 2024 Government Decides to Remove ‘Sharifa’s Story’ from School Textbook
  19. 28 June 2024 Ekattorer Ghatak Dalal Nirmul Committee Condemns Removal of ‘Sharifa’s Story’